Wednesday, June 19, 2013

Where have all the wildflowers gone? ..... (apart from the ones on the way to the airport).




We had a few days recently in Austria. One of the things I  had been looking forward to was seeing hay meadows. A long time ago (an embarrassingly long time ago) I had driven from Salzburg to Vienna over the mountains in early June and been blown away by the incredibly wildflower-rich meadows. One place I particularly remember, Iris sibirica was flowering amongst orchids and 'the usual' selection of ranunculus, knautia, lychnis, campanula etc. Traditional hay meadows have a high proportion of non-grasses to grass, many of which are very colourful wildflower species, so biodiversity is very high. The herb-rich grass makes for an interesting chemistry for the cows to eat, and is one of the main factors behind the very distinctive taste of Bergkäse - mountain cheese.

Where have all the flowers gone? Into plastic bags, every one.

This time I saw very few wildflowers - the reason being that farmers have largely gone over to silage rather than hay as a means of storing grass to feed to cattle over the winter. Hay is a nightmare to make as it needs several days to dry, and things can go badly wrong if it is stored too wet (like spontaneous combustion!). As one farming website says "All in all hay is a vale of tears".  <http://www.farm-direct.co.uk/farming/stockcrop/grass/silagedet.html > Silage is the stuff that is stored in those big plastic bags that can be seen lining the edges of fields, or it is stored in a big 'clamp' on the farm. It is essentially a fermented grass, with a higher moisture content than hay. Though it is difficult for us to believe, it is more palatable and digestible for the cows than hay.


Silage is cut earlier than hay, before most of the wildflowers in the grass flower and certainly before they seed. The bad news is: a huge drop in wildflowers and for biodiversity; it must be particularly bad news for pollinators such as bees. I discussed this with some Austrian colleagues who said that in some areas where conservation is more of a priority, there are subsidies for farmers who make hay rather than silage, but otherwise, no, over the last ten years there has been a huge increase in silage at the expense of wildflowers.

In Britain and the Netherlands farmers had done this for some time, and is part of the reason for the almost total disappearance of hay meadows - along with conversion to ryegrass monocultures and increased use of nitrogen-rich fertilisers (which include organic as well as synthetic fertiliser). Farmers have to make a living, so one can hardly blame them. In addition to which, not many farmers have any real interest in conservation (although more do now than in the past). There is no real difference between organic and non-organic either. The marketing departments of the organic food industry like to portray their products as being in tune with nature and conservation friendly, but the fact is that they are under the same economic pressures as anyone else - even more so, as organic farming is about 35% less productive per acre or hectare than non-organic, and is therefore a greater enemy of biodiversity than non-organic as it means considerably more land has to be farmed in the first place.

We have several acres of grassland on the England/Wales border, which has an interesting wildflower flora, in places very diverse indeed, and we try to manage it for wildflower biodiversity as well as we can. In this way we are very similar to many other middle-class people who have moved to the country and bought land which is now too uneconomic to farm. Some people (and a lot do this in Austria) get in a local farmer to cut their grass - mostly this means silage of course, although a few in our area still do hay. But trying to get a local farmer in to do anything is a complete nightmare - cutting a small field for not much economic return is hardly a priority for them, added to which is a completely different attitude to time and to commitment (a polite way of saying that they often seem to be utterly hopeless at getting things done, keeping you informed, and in the case of one local character never knowing what the weather is going to do - yes really! - to be brutally frank, I think a lot of small farmers are actually pretty bad at what they do).  There is of course no understanding of priorities for biodiversity management.

On the big scale, the preservation of hay meadows will only happen if farmers and landowners are given an economic reason to do so, i.e. subsidies. I am not generally a fan of subsidies, which are a vote-bank for politicians in many cases (just look at the farmers of the US Midwest, a great case of welfare-dependency if ever there was one), but here we can argue that through subsidies for conservation-friendly practices, we as taxpayers are paying for a product - biodiversity, which in turn can benefit tourism. On the small scale, an interesting example of people getting together is the Monmouthshire Meadows Group where people in the lower Wye valley, many of them with very small areas of hay meadow have banded together to share experiences and have bought an alpine hay baler so enabling them to make hay on a small scale and so preserve their wildflower rich meadows.

Actually in Austria, we did get to see some fantastic wildflowers, with one of the most biodiverse and colourful places I have ever seen in Europe - when we were on our way back to the airport. This has happened before - I remember Roy Diblik taking me to Chicago O'Hare Airport and stopping to look at the wonderfully named Shoe Factory Road Prairie on the way. Eichkogel, just south of Mödling, is a limestone hillock with a long history of management for hay cutting and a fantastically diverse dry meadow flora. Famous amongst Austrian botanists apparently. A wonderful way to end a trip.

Melampyrum arvense - a semi-parasite makes a dramatic splash at Eichkogel.




9 comments:

Anne Wareham said...

One thing that depresses me is people digging up ancient pasture in order to make a 'meadow' of annual flowers.(yes, they do)

The term 'meadow' itself may have something to answer for in the hort world.

And maybe other places could follow Monmouthshire Meadows' initiative. Once people have learnt just what is in their fields or what their fields could do, properly managed, real enthusiasm follows.

Monmouthshire Meadows have just published a book celebrating their 10th anniversary see http://www.monmouthshiremeadows.org.uk/?p=1460

XXXXX

Anne Wareham said...

One thing that depresses me is people digging up ancient pasture in order to make a 'meadow' of annual flowers.(yes, they do)

The term 'meadow' itself may have something to answer for in the hort world.

And maybe other places could follow Monmouthshire Meadows' initiative. Once people have learnt just what is in their fields or what their fields could do, properly managed, real enthusiasm follows.

Monmouthshire Meadows have just published a book celebrating their 10th anniversary see http://www.monmouthshiremeadows.org.uk/?p=1460

Anne Wareham said...

One thing that depresses me is people digging up ancient pasture in order to make a 'meadow' of annual flowers.(yes, they do)

The term 'meadow' itself may have something to answer for in the hort world.

And maybe other places could follow Monmouthshire Meadows' initiative. Once people have learnt just what is in their fields or what their fields could do, properly managed, real enthusiasm follows.

Monmouthshire Meadows have just published a book celebrating their 10th anniversary see http://www.monmouthshiremeadows.org.uk/?p=1460

Blogger being peculiar as ever - sorry if this comes up multiple or blank....

Roger Brook said...

Its good to hear someone suggesting (perhaps) that so many wild flower gardens are so artificial and contrived. The best wildflower meadows are the ones that come naturally from traditional methods of farming.
Having said that my own methods in my cemetery gardens are pretty artificial!

Rachel Callaghan said...

This is really interesting to hear. I am from a rural background (in New Zealand) and had never considered the impact of baleage (as we call it when it is wrapped)as opposed to hay-making. As always it comes down to practicalities. There has to be a compromise in there somewhere? Even leaving nature strips of longer grass/flowers between the fields? In NZ we are desperately fencing off and planting all waterways to prevent soil erosion and farm run-off into the waterways (stopping livestock from entering the streams). This in turn, of course, creates great areas of seeding grasses, clover etc, where no grazing or cropping takes place. Does the UK still have the hedgerows, or have they been replaced by fences? As usual, a thought-provoking issue!

Ewa said...

Hi Noel,
Just discovered your blog and if you don't mind, I will add it to my blogroll.

BTW how easy it is to recreate the nature? How much natural is something arranged by human hand ?

Brigitte Rieser said...

Sadly, you missed out the field trip on Sunday 9th, to the so called Fischaschlingen some 20km SE of Vienna. Very interesting and almost as famous, amongsts florists, as the Eichkogel area. Damp old riverbed interspersed with dry mounds. So, the flora of damp meadows (e.g. Iris sanguinea) virtually two steps from the flora of dry grasslands as I. spuria. Kinda weird.
Flora includes Veronica austriaca, Adenophora, many orchids, Apium repens, and so forth.

best
Brigitte

Marta Góra said...

Similar issue exists in Poland, wild meadows disappear:(

jayneonweedstreet said...

Absolutely fascinating piece! I had no idea about the hay meadows! But I do know that drives from Connecticut to the farmlands of New York State don't have the show of wildflowers don't show the profusion of wildflowers as the last century!